Farmaajo Will Be Re-elected, But He Won’t Have a Country to Rule

By Hassan Keynan

Prediction and byzantine Somali politics do not easily mix. Nevertheless, one could take a chance to predict that President Farmaajo and Company are likely to return to power. He will NOT come back through fair play. Fair and credible elections do not seem to be top among his priorities. His fortune leader saw the stars aligned for the great leader.

Farmaajo will return through a combination of factors: sheer ambition, will, early planning, effective organization, well-resourced mobilization, uncompromising commitment and singular determination to achieve results by any means necessary. He is arrogant and opportunistic, and stops at nothing to get what he wants. Farmaajo will use violence, intimidation, blackmail, deception and fraud to get him re-elected. He will not even hesitate to commit treason if it delivers for him. Variations of all these elements have been evident from the day Farmaajo was elected President in February 2017.

Farmaajo and Hassan Khaire are unmatched in the relentless, ruthless, merciless, and shameless manner in which they exploit and cynically manipulate the Constitution, national sovereignty, patriotic sentiments, clan politics, state authority and assets, executive powers and privileges, legislative and regulatory bodies and instruments, electoral laws, diplomatic protocols, and bilateral and multilateral relations. State and regulatory capture on a scale unparalleled in the annals of Somali politics.

Qatar and Ethiopiaare also two key and heavily consequential factors in Farmaajo’s strategic and electoral calculus. Qatar provides cash, guns, and sophisticated security and surveillance capabilities, coupled with robust political, diplomatic and media support. In fact, there is a growing realization among Western observers and influential African actors that Somalia has become a Qatari Satellite outpost run by top-notch Qatari assets. Ethiopia’s contribution is less sophisticated, medieval and quite crude, but nevertheless effective. It’s deployed in the form of brute military force to intimidate Farmaajo’s opponents, dismantle autonomous federal governance structures, and fraudulently alter the electoral landscape.

Naive opposition. Farmaajo’s ambition and prospects have been enhanced by weak, divided, low-ambition and in some respect naive opposition forces. With the exception of a few, Farmaajo’s political competitors do not seem to understand what they’re up against. They blindly appeal to constitutional, legal and legislative institutions that have been captured, compromised or gutted. They tend to believe that good intentions, common sense, and/or patriotic duty will prevail in contexts and environments dominated by deceit, predatory instincts, and partisan agendas. They insist on adherence to the 4-year constitutional term limit when the incumbent is hell bent on constantly bending the rule, changing the rules of the game, or moving the goal post. And they tend to leave serious matters to chance and luck. Every time Farmaajo and opposition forces meet, the former gets what he wants, i.e. results.  The latter get token compromises, empty promises, or platitudes.

Short-lived victory. Although Farmaajo is likely to return to power, his reign is unlikely to last long or end peacefully. He might be forced to leave power with plenty of regret, diminished fortunes, and ruinous legacy. And most tragically without a country. The end might be eerily similar to the tragic events of early 1991.

Unknown scenario. All political dispensations contain many unknowns that could take the form of unexpected blessings or nasty surprises. Somali politics is particularly and inherently prone to this phenomenon. One unknown is that Farmaajo’s formidable re-election bid might falter and eventually fail spectacularly. And the opposition might pull off a mighty win. A second Unknown is that Farmaajo and Company might win and manage to hold on to power for a full second 4-year term.

The coming six months will be heavy with both huge expectations and corrosive anxieties.

Hassan Keynan is a former Professor and a senior retired UN official who worked in Africa, Asia and Europe

keynanhassan@yahoo.com

Tyranny And Kleptocracy: Ethiopia’s Chronic Afflictions

Colonel Abiy Ahmed Ali
By Hassan Keynan

Ethiopian leaders and political class do not see nor do they hear the evil and ugly demons residing in the inner sanctum of their empire. Ethiopia suffers from multiple perennial afflictions. The two most lethal ones are tyranny and kleptocracy.

Tyranny

Tyranny has deeper roots in Ethiopia and it has robbed Ethiopians of their freedom, liberty, and dignity. From its inception Ethiopia has been synonymous with tyranny. During the past 130 years one tyrant replaced another. Each tyrant did what all tyrants do best: terrorize the people they call their own.

From the reign of Menelik to the rule of Meles, tyranny held sway. And in the end tyranny had tormented both the architects and dispensers of terror and its teeming victims. As a result, peace has eluded Meneliks palace. And liberty and basic human dignity have eluded the masses.

The rule of tyrants self-destructs.

Kleptocracy

Kleptocracy also has deeper roots in Ethiopia. The rule of thieves has deprived Ethiopians of their wealth and livelihoods. Between 1980 to 2018 the political elite looted over $84 billion dollars, according to the Illicit Financial Flows in Africa (2020) report.  For 38 years, the occupants of Meneliks palace on average stole $2 billion and $200 million every single year.

In the end the looted billions could not keep the predatory cabal in power. They stole but they did not live or find peace to enjoy their ill-gotten gains. However, they succeeded in keeping their populations in a permanent state of misery, poverty, and illiteracy.

The rule of thieves intoxicates leaders and impoverishes citizens.

7th King, Prosperity Party, and GERD

The self-declared 7th King of Ethiopian is not capable of changing this tragic reality. Abiy Ahmed Ali idolizes the 1st King, Menelik, the 1st tyrant and founding hegemon. He worships his mentor and role model, the 6th King Meles Zenawi. This means that Abiy Ahmed Ali gets inspiration from Ethiopias two worst tyrants. He is therefore unlikely to save Ethiopia from its two most lethal afflictions: tyranny and kleptocracy. In fact, Abiy Ahmed may well outperform all his predecessors in both as he is the most inexperienced, erratic and delusion-prone leader Ethiopia has ever known.

The much-hyped Grand Ethiopian Renaissance Dam (GERD) is not likely to make any difference either. Tyrants and kleptocrats mess nations up, especially poor ones, with undeveloped political, legislative, and judicial institutions.

Grand Ethiopian Renaissance Dam

The GERD costs $4.6 billion. And the narrative peddled by Abiy and company is that the GERD will miraculously transform the economy and livelihoods of Ethiopians. Just imagine the difference the $84 billion that were stolen would have made in the lives of ordinary Ethiopians had the money been appropriately invested.

Currently, the Prosperity Party (PP) is using and exploiting the GERD to whip poverty-stricken masses into a frenzy of nationalistic fervor directed at what is portrayed as an Egyptian plot to question Ethiopia’s sovereignty over the waters of the Blue Nile. It is true that Cairo is pursuing its own strategic interest; and would do everything in its power to win its protracted confrontation with Ethiopia over the management of the mighty Nile. However, it is equally true that PM Abiy Ahmed and PP have another agenda hidden within the broader and inherently complex Nile agenda. Abiy Ahmed and his political allies are likely to win if a water war breaks out between Egypt and Ethiopia. War with Egypt would certainly deepen tyranny and repression at home. And if there isn’t war with Cairo, Abiy Ahmed might provoke one in another country, one much closer to home. Peace is not on the mind of the 2019 Nobel Peace Laureate. They will win even if the dispute is settled peacefully. A peaceful settlement would probably further entrench kleptocracy and mass poverty. In both scenarios poor Ethiopians would not only loose; they would also suffer the humiliation and trauma of being deceiving into becoming actively and willingly complicit in their enslavement and impoverishment. It’s scary. 

No party with the name Prosperity has ever ushered in an era of plenty in any country anywhere.

 Let freedom reign! Prosperity will follow.

 

Hassan Keynan is a former Professor and a senior retired UN official who worked in Africa, Asia and Europe